The AP Poll was released Sunday afternoon and by now College Football and the contenders for the 1st ever College Football Playoff have been discussed ad nauseam.  It’s time to get to some of the actual action.  We are 10 days from the start of the College Football Season when Texas A&M and South Carolina kick it off it Williams-Brice Stadium.

One of the conversations that happened a year ago was a Kentucky fan claiming that Clemson “is always over-rated in the pre-season.”

That claim got me thinking…….in the last 10 years what programs have under OR over-performed pre-season expectations as it relates to the Pre-Season & Final AP Poll.

What I Thought I Would Find

I wanted to set my expectations prior to aggregating data so that I could evaluate any bias that I personally held against schools OR conferences.   I believed that programs like Ohio State, Notre Dame, Michigan, and USC would likely be towards the top of the OVER-RATED crowd and programs from non-Power leagues that have performed well over the past decade would be near the top of the UNDER-RATED group; like Boise, Cincinnati, and Louisville.    I also took note to evaluate the alleged “West Coast Bias” that is discussed each season as the claim from out west is that voters tend to overlook teams in the Mountain & Pacific Time Zones.

How I Calculated

To have an evaluation of bias, I thought it would be prudent to have a simple and unbiased way of calculating the results.  So with this, it’s as unscientific as it gets:  #1 in the Poll=1.  #25 in the Poll=25.  #NR in the Poll=26.  The scale goes from 1-26, if a team like USC in 2012 started the season #1 and finished unranked, their score was -25 (1-26= -25). If a team started outside of the Poll Pre-Season, like Texas A&M in 2012 and finished #6 in the Final Poll their score was 20 (26-6=20).  The final result would be the cumulative result of the 10 seasons that have been played since 2004.  I made the cutoff at 15 +/- (or an average difference of 1.5 positions per year). It’s just math.

Most Pre-Season Over-Rated Since 2004

Oklahoma -56
Florida State -51
Georgia -46
Michigan -46
Florida -44
Nebraska -42
Texas -42
California -35
Miami (FL) -33
LSU -32
USC -32
Tennessee -29
WVU -26
Clemson -17
Ohio State -16

Oklahoma in the past decade is the most OVER-Rated program in the Pre-Season closely followed by Florida State.  Oklahoma’s -56 represents a 5.6 spot over-ranking over the past 10 seasons.

It is curious that Florida State (the defending national champion) is listed 2nd.  But they aren’t listed here because of what the Seminoles did LAST YEAR, rather the Noles are listed here because of the 2004, 2005, 2006, 2007, 2009, and 2011 seasons.  In fact, Florida State only finished ahead of their pre-season ranking in 3 of the past 10 AP Polls.

Oklahoma also improved their position in 2013 as a result of going from #16 in the preseason to #6 in the Final Poll, but the damage for the decade-long look was already done.  We can specifically point to the 2005 season (#7 to #22), 2009 season (#3 to Not Ranked), 2011 season (#1 to #16), and 2012 season (#4 to #15) as the reason for the Sooners owning the #1 most OVER-RATED program.

Over-Rated Conference Breakdown

SEC:  4 (Georgia, Florida, LSU, Tennessee)
ACC: 3 (Florida State, Miami, Clemson)
Big 10: 3 (Michigan, Nebraska, Ohio State)
Big 12:  3  (Oklahoma, Texas, West Virginia)
PAC 12: 2 (Cal, USC)

Most Pre-Season Under-Rated Since 2004

Utah 41
Auburn 41
Boise State 40
Cincinnati 37
TCU 33
Boston College 30
Michigan State 30
Stanford 29
Alabama 27
Baylor 26
Missouri 25
Central Florida 21
BYU 21
Mississippi 18
Texas Tech 17
Oregon State 17
Penn State 16

Utah & Auburn are tied for the Most Under-Rated program in the AP Pre-Season Poll the last decade followed closely by Boise State.  The Utes and Tigers +41 represents a 4.1 spot under-ranking each year for the past decade.  Utah made tremendous progress in 2008 when the Utes began unranked and finished #2 in the Final AP Poll.  Similarly for Auburn in 2013 when the Tigers started the season unranked and finished #2 in the final poll.

Auburn also made huge leaps in 2004 (#17 to #2) and 2010 (#22 to #1) , and took a major blow in 2008 (#10 to NR).  Overall, the Tigers started in the Pre-Season Poll on 7 occasions and finished in the Final Poll in 6 of the past 10 seasons.  Utah started in the preseason Top 25 just twice in the past decade and finished in the Top 25 three times.  Utah also hasn’t appeared in the Pre or Final AP Poll since 2009 and will likely take a huge fall in next year’s decade evaluation when the +16 2004 result is no longer used.

Schools like Boise State +40, Cincinnati +37, and TCU +33 have more steady data, but a big surprise on the list was Alabama +27.  The Crimson Tide make the list as a result of the 2005 (vacated) season (NR to #8),  the 2008 season (#24 to #6).  Since the 2008 season however, there hasn’t been much room for Alabama to build on their under-rated status as the Tide have been ranked towards the top of the Top 25 and haven’t given many positions back over the past decade.

Under-Rated Conference Breakdown: 17

SEC: 4 (Auburn, Alabama, Missouri, Ole Miss)
Big 12: 3 (TCU, Baylor, Texas Tech)
Pac-12: 3 (Utah, Stanford, Oregon State)
American Athletic: 2 (Cincinnati, Central Florida)
Big 10: 2 (Michigan State, Penn State)
Mountain West: 1 (Boise State)
ACC: 1 (Boston College)
Independent: 1 (BYU)

The Most Accurately Ranked Programs Since 2004 

Note if you don’t see your program listed in the over/under/or accurately ranked categories it is because they have not been in the Pre-Season or Final Top 25 Poll Since dating back to 2000 (ahem, Kentucky).  Negative outputs here list programs that are teetering towards being over-rated and positive outputs represent teams that are flirting with under-rated status.  I made the cut-off for “accurate” rankings to be within an average of 1.5 spots within the past decade.

North Carolina -13
Purdue -13
Texas A&M -12
Virginia Tech -12
Iowa -10
Georgia Tech -8
Virginia -8
South Florida -7
Southern Miss -6
Pittsburgh -3
Maryland -1
Minnesota -1
Bowling Green 0
Colorado 0
Colorado St 0
Iowa State 0
Illinois 0
Marshall 0
Miami (OH) 0
Syracuse 0
Toledo 0
Washington St 0
NC State 1
Oklahoma State 1
Washington 1
Freno St 2
Navy 2
Tulsa 2
Central Michigan 3
Duke 3
Arizona State 4
Hawai’i 4
Notre Dame 4
Northern Illinois 4
Rutgers 4
Arkansas 5
Mississippi St 5
Northwestern 5
San Jose State 5
Vanderbilt 5
Wake Forest 5
Kansas 6
Wisconsin 6
Kansas State 7
Houston 8
Louisville 10
South Carolina 10
Utah State 10
Oregon 12
Nevada 15

 My Thoughts After Findings

I knew coming in to this exercise that Florida State had some lean years prior to the transition of Bobby Bowden to Jimbo Fisher and did not meet expectations.  So FSU being in the over-rated category despite being national champions in 2013-14 was not a surprise.  This is, after all, a long-time review for bias of Football Writers……not football programs.  So the opinion of those that vote in the AP Poll is really what we are trying to prove here.

Oklahoma and Georgia are interesting at the top of the over-rated group because Bob Stoops and Mark Richt have been at the helm during this time with no change anticipated and both coaches in their mid-50s.

The Under-Rated Category did take me by surprise in that 4 SEC programs (in addition to 4 SEC teams in the Over-Rated Category) made the group.  I expected the Boise, Utah, Cincinnati, and TCU crowd here.  And Stanford really has made outstanding strides since the 2010 season.


If you want the spreadsheet that I used to calculate this I will gladly send it over (request via Twitter @UofLSheriff50).  It is too large to insert into a post, but I’ll give you an idea of what it would look like if I did insert it (unreadable).  Clicking the image makes it larger, but still unreadable.


2014 Pre-Season Top 25

Rank Team Average Deviation
1 Florida St -5.1
2 Alabama 2.7
3 Oregon 1.2
4 Oklahoma -5.6
5 Ohio St -1.6
6 Auburn 4.1
7 UCLA 0.3
8 Michigan St 3.0
9 South Carolina 1.0
10 Baylor 2.6
11 Stanford 2.9
12 Georgia -4.6
13 LSU -3.2
14 Wisconsin 0.6
15 USC -3.2
16 Clemson -1.7
17 Notre Dame 0.4
18 Ole Miss 1.8
19 Arizona St 0.4
20 Kansas St 0.7
21 Texas A&M -1.2
22 Nebraska -4.2
23 North Carolina -1.3
24 Missouri 2.5
25 Washington 0.1
The following two tabs change content below.
@UofLSheriff50. Louisville native, University of Louisville Business School Grad c/o 2004. Co-Founder of

TCZ Comments